2026 Case: Ballan v. Chesapeake Corrections, Inc. and Dylan Oberfeld
A New Look for the Mock Trial Casebook
This year’s Casebook will look a little different! It includes only the core “case file” materials—Pleadings, Stipulations, Special Instructions/Stipulations, and Affidavits/Depositions—along with the rubric and score sheet. All other resources and materials, including Exhibits, will now be available right here on our website. In future years, expect all materials to be online.
There are changes to some of the rules, language, and procedures this year, too. Read Parts I-IV thoroughly. To highlight a couple of changes:
Closing Arguments: Closings will now follow real-world courtroom procedure in that Plaintiff/Prosecution goes first, followed by Defense, followed by (if time permits and Plaintiff/Prosecution desires) a rebuttal by the Plaintiff/Prosecution. The time limit for closings have increased from 7 to 8 minutes. [Maryland Mock Trial Procedures XI]
Team Information Exchange: In addition to witness gender exchange, Plaintiff’s counsel must inform Defendants’ counsel no less than 24 hours in advance of the competition start time, which counts they will pursue at trial. Plaintiff's counsel shall inform the Court which Counts will be pursued during the Court’s hearing of preliminary matters prior to trial. [Stipulations/ Rulings #2]
-
-
-
Micah Ballan
Miller Gonikman
Zion Herman
Download all Plaintiff Affidavits (includes corrected documents) -
Aiden Chester
Dylan Oberfeld
Sam Shrubstok
Download all Defense Affidavits (includes corrected documents) -
Original; has not been updated to include corrections.
We are incredibly grateful to Local 3 News in Chattanooga, TN and former MYLaw Mock Trial/ Franklin High students for lending their talent and creativity to produce a “faux newscast” inspired by this year’s Maryland Mock Trial case. Logan Dubel attends University of Texas and is in Broadcast Journalism. Jenifer Fridman, UM grad, is a third year law student at Georgetown University. Maddie Ballan, UM grad, currently works for the US government. Our congratulations to Logan, Maddie and Jen on their incredible success.
Download all exhibits - updated to include corrected documents
Exhibit 1: USCA Standards
Exhibit 2: CCI Code of Conduct
Exhibit 3: Inmate Grievance Procedures
Exhibit 4: Warden Chester Resume
Exhibit 5: Shrubstok Fingerprint Response
Exhibit 6: Herman Fingerprint Response
Exhibit 7: Ballan Mental Health
Exhibit 8: Prison Block Photo
Exhibit 9: Ballan Grievance 756-8
Exhibit 10: Ballan Grievance 472-9
Exhibit 11: Ballan Grievance 325-9
Exhibit 12: Ballan Grievance 613-7, 613-4
Exhibit 13: Ballan Grievance 613-4
Exhibit 14: Basketball Court
Exhibit 15: Emergency Care Report
Exhibit 16: Ballan-Herman Grievance 826-1
Exhibit 17: Ballan Protective Custody Cell
Exhibit 18: Ballan Grievance 921-3
Exhibit 19: Ballan Psychiatric Evaluations
Exhibit 20: Ballan Diary
Exhibit 21: Ballan Jail Cell
Exhibit 22: Medical Report Ballan
Exhibit 23: Medical Report Oberfeld
Exhibit 24: Ballan-Shrubstok -Oberfeld Grievance 914-7
Exhibit 25: Ballan Solitary Confinement
Exhibit 26: Dr. Singh Email
Exhibit 27: Confinement Extensions